Outstanding Reality-competition Program - 2004

American Idol
FOX
- Paula Abdul, Judge
- Charles Boyd, Senior Producer
- Simon Cowell, Judge
- Cecile Frot-Coutaz, Executive Producer
- Simon Fuller, Executive Producer
- David Goffin, Supervising Producer
- Randy Jackson, Judge
- Nigel Lythgoe, Executive Producer
- Beth McNamara, Producer
- Ryan Seacrest, Host
- Ken Warwick, Executive Producer

- Peter Engel, Executive Producer
- Rob Fox, Co-Executive Producer
- Cori Fry, Producer
- Barry Katz, Executive Producer
- Brittany Lovett, Producer
- Jay Mohr, Executive Producer/Host
- Leslie Radakovich, Supervising Producer
- Javier Winnik, Producer

Survivor
CBS
- Craig Armstrong, Co-Executive Producer
- Maria Baltazzi, Producer
- Bruce Beresford-Redman, Supervising Producer
- Adam Briles, Producer
- Mark Burnett, Executive Producer
- Viki Cacciatore, Supervising Producer
- David Dryden, Senior Producer
- Eden Gaha, Producer
- John Kirhoffer, Producer
- Doug McCallie, Producer
- Dan Munday, Producer
- Cathrine Nilsen, Producer
- Charlie Parsons, Executive Producer
- Jeff Probst, Producer/Host
- Conrad Riggs, Producer
- Tom Shelly, Co-Executive Producer
- Holly M. Wofford

The Amazing Race
CBS
- Jerry Bruckheimer, Executive Producer
- Amy Nabseth Chacon
- Brady Connell, Producer
- Elise Doganieri, Producer
- Anthony Dominici, Supervising Producer
- Julian Grimmond, Producer
- Phil Keoghan, Host
- Jon Kroll, Co-Executive Producer
- Jonathan Littman, Executive Producer
- Shannon McGinn, Producer
- Michael Norton, Producer
- Michael Noval, Producer
- Bob Parr, Producer
- Rick Ringbakk, Supervising Producer
- Bertram van Munster, Executive Producer
- Hayma "Screech" Washington
- Evan Weinstein, Senior Producer

The Apprentice
NBC
- Jay Bienstock, Co-Executive Producer
- James Bruce, Producer
- Mark Burnett, Executive Producer
- James Canniffe, Producer
- Seth Cohen, Producer
- Kevin Harris, Supervising Producer
- Bill Pruitt, Producer
- Conrad Riggs, Co-Executive Producer
- Donald Trump, Executive Producer
- Katherine Walker, Producer